A Premise That Should Not Work — But Does
On paper, the combination sounds like a creative stretch. Take the samsui women — those stoic, red-headscarved Cantonese labourers who helped build colonial Singapore brick by brick — and throw them into a wuxia martial arts narrative against the Orang Minyak, a supernatural oily predator lifted straight from Malay folklore. It sounds like a pitch meeting gone sideways. In execution, it is one of the most coherent, organically Singaporean stories you will read this year.
The secret lies in how deeply Gotham understands both worlds he is drawing from. The samsui women were not fragile historical footnotes. They were hardworking, fiercely independent women who operated in a dangerous, male-dominated environment — making them natural candidates for a wuxia protagonist. Framing Gui’er’s story against the real historical backdrop of Nanyang gives the narrative an emotional grounding that pure fantasy cannot manufacture. You are not just rooting for a fictional hero. You are rooting for a figure that represents something real in Singapore’s collective memory.
The Art Is, Simply Put, Exceptional
Let us not bury the lead: Gotham can draw. Beautifully. The linework carries a kinetic energy that gives action sequences genuine weight and momentum — but what truly elevates the art is the facial expression work. Emotions land without a single word of dialogue needed. Grief, resolve, rage, quiet dignity — all of it lives in the characters’ faces with a precision that many professional studio productions fail to achieve.
For a self-published, hobbyist work, the visual quality is frankly startling. This is not rough-edged passion project art. This is considered, disciplined, accomplished craft.
The Storytelling Is Tight and Unafraid
The narrative structure of Vol. 1 is compact and efficient — no bloated preamble, no meandering subplots. Gotham respects the reader’s intelligence and time. The story moves with purpose, and every scene earns its place. Crucially, the story is not afraid to make hard narrative choices. Real stakes are established early. Things happen that cannot be undone. The emotional weight this creates is what separates a memorable story from a merely entertaining one.
The element that surprised me most, however, is what Gotham does with Gui’er’s combat system. Rather than inventing generic martial arts flourishes, he has rooted her special techniques in Chinese idioms — 成语. The result is something genuinely clever: moves that feel culturally authentic, visually inventive, and not even slightly cringey. That last part is harder to achieve than it sounds. It is the kind of creative decision that reveals an author who has thought carefully about his material, not just drawn cool fights.
Why This Matters for Singapore
Singapore has a complicated relationship with its own stories. We consume narratives from everywhere else — American comics, Japanese manga, Korean webtoons — while our own history, folklore, and cultural memory sit waiting to be told in compelling form. The Samsui Sword is proof that those stories, when handled with skill and sincerity, can stand alongside the best of them.
The samsui women deserve to be remembered. The Orang Minyak is genuinely ours — one of the few supernatural figures that emerged from a 1957 Berita Harian report, embedded in the shared subconscious of this region. Seeing both woven into a single story, treated with craft and respect rather than campy nostalgia, feels like something overdue.
The Verdict
The Samsui Sword Vol. 1 is excellent. Not “pretty good for local.” Not “worth supporting because Singaporean.” Excellent, full stop. Sharp art, emotionally resonant storytelling, culturally intelligent world-building, and a protagonist worth following across many more volumes.
I finished it and ordered Vol. 2 immediately. I have no regrets.
The Samsui Sword is published by Rojak City Pte. Ltd. and available at Maha Yu Yi (裕意) bookstore at 231 Bain Street #03-07, as well as online at yuyi.com.sg. At under $20 a volume, it is a small price to pay to own something genuinely special — and to put money directly into the hands of a local artist who has earned it. Buy a copy. Then buy one for someone else.
This post was written with assistance from Claude.
Previous Next